A Stricter Ruler Turns 90% of UK Foods "Unhealthy"

•2 min read

Last week, a study in BMJ Medicine put the same British packaged foods under different official rulers and watched the "unhealthy" share jump. On many packs, a traffic-light label uses green, amber, and red to flag fat, salt, and sugar. A shopper who steers away from red may still be holding a product that another government score would call too high in those same nutrients.

Researchers compared 262 processed foods and 1,636 ultra-processed foods from the UK's national diet survey for 2019-20. Ultra-processed foods are the factory-made products that often come with extra fat, sugar, salt, or additives. They did not include fresh fruit, vegetables, and other lightly processed foods, so the results describe packaged products, not the whole diet.

The traffic-light system, which is voluntary on real shelves, classed just over 48 percent of the ultra-processed foods as unhealthy, and about 46 percent of the processed foods. A nutrient score used in UK food regulation, often called the Food Standards Agency model, raised those shares to nearly 58 percent and 50 percent. The two rulers already disagree on the same items, in part because the lights use looser cut-offs, and the agency score can let fibre, protein, or fruit points cancel out fat, sugar, and salt.

The gap grew when the team built new scores from the official Eatwell diet guide, which sets limits on fat, saturated fat, free sugars, and salt. Under the first of those scores, 91.5 percent of the ultra-processed foods counted as unhealthy. When total fat and then energy density were added, the share rose to almost 95 percent and then about 98 percent. Processed foods moved in the same direction: from about half under today's labels to more than 90 percent under the Eatwell-based scores. Swapping the ruler nearly doubled the "unhealthy" pile.

Ready meals, sandwiches, and fast food were among the products that looked worse once the stricter guide was applied. The researchers say the current systems leave foods with extra fat, sugar, or salt unmarked. Their closing argument is that one shared definition, lined up with official diet advice, would stop the same pack from carrying two official verdicts. For a shopper who has learned to dodge the red lights, that is the study in one line: the colors on the front are only one ruler, and a stricter one, built from the Eatwell guide, puts far more of the same foods on the unhealthy side of the line.